Questions about enlightenment


Spirituality &
The Brain (Home Page)
Other pages on this site:

The God Helmet

________

Psychic Technology

________

Deja Vu

________

Living in Gratitude

________

Spiritual Coaching
– Crises
– Guidance
– Learning
– More
________

Darwinian Reincarnation

________

Conscious-ness

________

Romantic Love and the Brain

________
Origins of spirituality in Human Evolution

________

Shakti – Magnetic Brain Stimulation

________

Sacred Lands

________

“The Sensed Presence”

________
Glasses
For Enhanced Visual Acuity

________

God in the Brain

________

Spiritual Aptitude Test

________

Stimulating My Brain
As A Spiritual Path

________

Inventing Shakti

________

Sex & States of Conscious-ness

________

Evolution and The Gay Male Brain

________

Visions

________

The Spiritual Personality

________

The Buddha’s Brain.
________

Archetypes

________

A Diet For Epileptics?

________

Odd Experiences – Online Poll Results

________

Out
Of
Body Experiences

________

Near-Death Experiences – Thai Case histories

________

The Big Bang

________

Meditations from Brain Science

________

Near-Death Experience in Thailand – Case Histories

________

The Terrorist Brain

________

Credentials

________

Hippocrates on Epilepsy

________

PRIVACY POLICY

________

Contact Us

.

 

Questions about Enlightenment

Q.
Your paper on ‘enlightenment and the brain‘ is a fine piece of work and makes absolute sense. At the end you say that one’s enlightenment is not that of the other; are you aware of that the two most recent ‘Enlightened’ Masters, J. Krishnamurti and the controversial Osho, promoted this personal process of ‘seeking’ enlightenment. Osho’s method was to utterly confuse people with logic, much like a Zen Buddhist koan would. Perhaps utter confusion (which is a common thing for anyone) would also elevate the brain’s activity over a certain threshold and would allow for a personal explosion. What are your thoughts on this?

A.
I think that “utter confusion” would only activate certain parts of the brain.

The Zen Koan Method does not involve ‘utter’ (total?) confusion. Rather, it would involve only the breakdown of logical thinking, and dramatic changes in the brain’s function will involve much more than that.

Although there are many famous stories about people becoming enlightened using it, there are no instances recent enough for the enlightened person to leave much of a legacy.

Enlightenment, as I see it, is a process very likely dominated by the temporal lobes. The search for cognitive strategies (which are failing when a person is confused) is one that will involve the frontal lobes. When the frontal lobes’ activity crosses a threshold, such that there is no possibility of thinking of a solution, it’s possible that the activity could spill over into the temporal lobes. The layout of “Cortico-cortical” pathways would make the temporal lobes the most likely place for it to go.

The result would be a sudden and dramatic activation of the temporal lobes, so heavily implicated in religious and mystic experiences.

However, this alone would not result in enlightenment.

You see, there are many pathways within the temporal lobes that could be activated in this process, most of them having nothing to do with enlightenment.

The sudden deactivation of the frontal lobes could leave the person feeling that their problem had been solved (The Koan resolved), and with that, the sense that the issue was resolved, but not through logical processes.

In other words, they might see that the ‘truth’ was ‘beyond thought’.

But the process would have nothing to do with either thought or truth.

The Koan method is a valid one, insofar as it would make for sudden and dramatic experiences, but it works with conscious thought and its failure.

Enlightenment, defined by the bliss that happens along with it (or at least the end of suffering), would require particular limbic/temporal pathways to be involved. Specifically, the amygdala, with it’s uniquely emotional functions. The Koan method, relying on thinking (and the breakdown of thought), is much more likely to involve cognitive structures (such as the hippocampus), so that the moment of breakthrough for a Koan will only culminate in an episode of ‘Satori’ – a temporary experience with only some features of enlightenment.

Not surprisingly, Zen does not teach that Koans are the best way to enlightenment. It places its emphasis on “Just Sitting”, sometimes called “choiceless awareness”.

Another point is that the process of completely confusing people is unpleasant, and can offer a justification for inflicting a painful process on people. I don’t see that Osho or Krishnamurti used that method (outside of a retreat in Osho’s Ashram where people asked themselves, repeatedly, “Who am I?”, and endlessly rejected the answers that appeared. But then “Who Am I?” isn’t a nonsense question, while “What is the sound of one hand clapping?” is.

J. Krishnamurti taught that there was nothing one could do to become enlightened, while Osho taught that the utter calm of enlightenment was best found after a storm. In fact, he based his most important yoga practice, “dynamic meditation” on that idea.

To answer your question (paraphrased):

Could utter confusion elevate the brain’s activity over a certain threshold and allow for a personal explosion?

Yes, but the explosion would probably not be in the direction of enlightenment for any but a very, very small percentage. For most people, it would be a waste of time.

End.

BACK to the enlightenment page

HOME page

EMAIL

 

 
Other Pages On This Site:

HOME PAGE

NEURAL STIMULATION:

The God Helmet   |   Shiva Psychic Technology
Shakti – Magnetic Brain Stimulation 
Inventing Shakti
Stimulating My Brain As A Spiritual Path

HUMAN EVOLUTION:

 Origins of spirituality in Human Evolution

Role of Mystics and mysticism in Human Evolution.

The Gay Male Brain in human evolution 

The Evolution of Human Belief in God

 Consciousness  |   Darwinian Reincarnation

SPIRITUAL
NEUROSCIENCE

Articles on neurotheology, (or – spirituality and religion meet brain science).

Enlightenment And the Brain
 Deja Vu  |   Meditations from Brain Science
Romantic Love and the Brain
 The Sensed Presence  |  God in the Brain
 Spiritual Aptitude Test  |   Sacred Lands
The Spiritual Personality  |   Archetypes  
Out-Of-Body Experiences  |   Visions
Odd Experiences – Online Poll Results

Podcasts on Neurotheology

OFF-SITE PAGES (OPEN IN NEW WINDOWS).

Different spiritual practices have different effects on the brain.  

NEAR-DEATH EXPERIENCES:

NDEs in Thailand – Discussion    |   Thai NDE Case histories 
 Darwinian Reincarnation

Near-Death Experience Screensaver (Entering the Light).

Epilepsy And Near-Death Experiences

BRAIN STUFF:

Glasses For Enhanced Visual Acuity
A Diet For Epileptics?
Sex & States of Consciousness 
Hippocrates on Epilepsy
 The Terrorist Brain

OTHER STUFF:

Real-Time Geomagnetic levels

Credentials
What Caused The Big Bang?
PRIVACY POLICY